Current Events

Passenger Tasered At Airport: "The Terminal" Meets Kafka

By Citizen Correspondent Russ Brown , Canada
Date Posted: 11/15/07
Reader Rating: rating

On October 13, 2007, Robert Dziekanski died at Vancouver International Airport after being "tasered" by the RCMP. CTV is reporting that he got into a "confrontation" with airport police. The Globe and Mail, on the other hand is reporting that Dziekanski was "agitated", "shouting" and "acting out" "aggressively". It has also been reported that he (gasp) "threw things". Is anyone as bothered as I am by the ambiguous terminology being used to justify sending 50,000 volts through this man's body?

What is known about Mr. Dziekanski's final hours before his death at police hands is this: He had flown to Vancouver from Poland - a trip paid for by his mother, a Kamloops, British Columbia resident, whom he was joining.

Confused after his long journey and unable to speak English, he was detained in a secure area of the airport for 10 hours. No explanation has been given for this detention. For seven of those 10 hours, his mother was also at the airport, waiting to greet him.

She was not told her son was being detained, or that he was even at the airport. After 10 hours, something happened (the "confrontation", the "shouting", the "aggressive" "acting out", the "throwing things") and he was tasered. He died.

His mother, who by this time had left the airport to return home to Kamloops, was informed of her son's death and told to return to the airport.

The state's account of this event verges on the Kafkaesque. Why was he detained? No explanation? What did he do to merit tasering? Oh, he was"agitated" and "aggressive". He "confronted" us. He "acted out". He "shouted". He "threw things".

At the risk of stating the obvious, were I detained at an airport for 10 hours after an international flight, I might well become "agitated" enough to "confront" someone in order to secure my release. Heck, I might even feel some "aggression".

And, if I didn't speak the local language, I might have to "act out" my sentiments in order to make them understood, or even succumb to the common (and futile) habit of "shouting" to surmount a language barrier.


1 | 2 next








Tags:

Comments

Re: Passenger Tasered At Airport: "The Terminal" Meets Kafka

By Trina Ricketts, November 20, 2007 at 11:12

That's just sick. Perhaps the majority of citizens who actually believe our police are out there to protect us will get it now. Increased enforcement - as is constantly cited as an important strategy for reducing crime - scares the hell out of me. In my experience and the experience of most people who have had a lot of police encounters in their lives - it is THE POLICE who are committing the most disgusting crimes. And they get away with it. While I realize there are some police officers out there who truly want to serve their cities with decent and compassionate enforcement, the majority of cops become cops for a reason. Power. The same reason people get into gangs. The brutality shown by police towards homeless people, street based sex workers, and the so-called criminals of our society (who incidentally are just doing what they can to survive for the most part) is out of control and much more common than anyone seems to realize or care. Scenes like this one at the airport show the truth about most of our "protectors." When will people wake up and smell the corruption? The only thing I feel when I see police is fear. And I haven't even done anything wrong. And yet our governments and our police forces are continually asking for more officers. Gimme a break. Spend some money on some decent, affordable housing, supports for people with mental health issues and addictions issues, and stop allowing our own people to STARVE. Then you will see a drop in crime. We don't need more ENFORCEMENT - like what is shown in this video. We need more love.

Re: Passenger Tasered At Airport: "The Terminal" Meets Kafka

By Hazel8500, November 19, 2007 at 14:28

Hi all, what a horrible thing, I've been horrified from day one, and am full of grief for this man and his family. I don't care if it was the taser or the knee to the neck that killed the man, both objects were wielded in the hands of our Royal Canadian Mounted Police. The RCMP is broken, and it is so terribly unfortunate because not only is the public being let down, not only are they besmirching our international reputation, they are also putting their own brave men and women at risk. Take a look at the recent deaths of RCMP officers in the North. The RCMP is systematically broken, I have no confidence in the red and white anymore, nor do I have any confidence of the RCMP's ability to self police themselves or handle an internal inquiry.

The Canadian citizens and visitors to this country deserve more than this.
And I am convinced its media operations such as Orato has great power to affect the situation for the better.

Orato is the best.

RIP Mr. Dziekanski, your death, is our loss and shame.

Hazel.

Re: Passenger Tasered At Airport: "The Terminal" Meets Kafka

By nomadic, November 19, 2007 at 08:47

When I first heard that a man was tasered to death in an Airport in Vancouver, I didn’t pay much attention. Maybe it was the steady flow of depressing news that filters ones consciousness on a daily basis, but for some reason the story didn’t shock my system. After all, police have shot and killed many innocent people before. And you don’t have to be a rocket scientist to know that Tasers are lethal.

But it was when the full story emerged that I became not only shocked, but saddened and ashamed. How had we, as so called peaceful Canadians let our RCMP force become so violent? I know that airports are a high security area. There are a few places that should never be vulnerable, and an airport definitely falls into that category. But when the video emerged, I didn’t see a threatening villain, but a frusterated Polish immigrant who had been asking for the officers help in a non-violent fashion, when he was tasered. Two things stuck out in my mind.

1. The man (Robert Dziekanski) was unarmed
2. He didn’t speak English
In the video, one of the RCMP officers asks excitedly, “Should I taser him???”.

It was as if the officer was playing a video game.

I did not see any of the officers try to figure out “why” he was upset. I didn’t see any of the officers trying to figure out how to communicate with him in his native tongue. I did not see them try to help him at all.
It seemed that the officers were amateur, freaked out and acted cowardly by using the taser in the first 25 sec of being in the mans presence.
People talk a lot about investigating what happened, punishing the officers or debating whether tasers should be used. But I hope that this terrible occurrence will also open up a larger discussion on race and stereotype in our country, and how we as humans relate to one another.

Nomadic
whatsreallygoodies.blogspot.com

Re: Passenger Tasered At Airport: "The Terminal" Meets Kafka

By Heather Wallace, November 15, 2007 at 18:16

I just returned from Europe. On my way there, I inadvertently passed through Vancouver International Airport, Heathrow and Gatwick security with a switchblade in my bag. I didn't discover it until we got to Venice and I unpacked a few things. It didn't make me feel very safe or give me much confidence in the airport security systems. This terrible incident is an awful case in point.

The RCMP obviously relied more on their "non-lethal" weapon than on psychological tactics to calm him. He was not armed, and between them, I think the RCMP could have cuffed him if they were concerned about their own security.

I just feel so sad for this man. I know after a long flight, I am always feeling more than a little crooked. I have never thrown anything, but I have been very emotional because of jetlag. This man had never flown before and didn't speak our language. He may have been a smoker, and was just getting desperate. He was likely already terrified about moving here, and then there was no one here to help him. I don't know what else to say - I just feel so bad for him, and I cried for him tonight.

One thing is not clear - As Robyn just asked, was it the taser shock that killed him, or the knee pinning him down? I heard the RCMP was pinning him with a knee to the throat. I think the internal investigation is worthless. I look forward to the independent one.

Heather Wallace
senior editor
Orato.com

Re: Passenger Tasered At Airport: "The Terminal" Meets Kafka

By Robyn Stubbs, November 15, 2007 at 17:21

I had a pretty strong reaction to seeing the video of the student who got tasered at the Kerry forum - this was just as bad, maybe worse. While the taser, in my untrained experience, did seem like unwarranted and excessive use of force, I can't help but think that the taser didn't actually kill this man - the cop's knee across his neck may have had something to do with it, though.

Either way, it's unbelievable and shocking. Welcome to Canada, Mr. Dziekanski.

Editor's Picks

Darfur Refugees: Don't Press-Gang Our Sons

By Citizen Correspondent Anna Schmitt
Through my humanitarian work in Central Africa, I learned that refugee children from... Full Story »