Pickton Trial

Legalization: Institutionalization Of Objectification

Lebow, brothel, prostitution, regulation

Painting by David Lebow. dlebow@maniaman.com.


The message we are sending our young boys is that just because you cannot control yourselves, we will make sure you...have women available for you to use and de-humanize. '
Trisha Baptie
Date Posted: 02/22/07
Reader Rating: rating

As I had imagined it would, during this serial killer trial the very sensitive issue of legalizing prostitution has reared its ugly head more than once. People raise the question: Would the sex trade be safer were we to legislate the buying and selling of human beings? Would legalization have saved these women's lives? If society provided a safe place for men and women to ply their trade, would they, in fact, be safe? I am going to go with a most emphatic NO!
*Editors Note: While the images that accompany this story illustrate the glamourization of prostitution, correspondent Trisha Baptie paints a very different picture.

Society should be more concerned with looking at the issues behind prostitution than offering the Band-Aid solution of legalization. We should hold our stand that it is illegal, for I think society has an obligation to watch out for those who cannot look after themselves. Anyone thinking that prostitution is a solution for anything is probably in need of some emotional assistance and a new perspective on what paths to take in life. So we should instead be looking at why so many women are resorting to it.

I am not sure I can wrap my mind around the buying and selling of a human being, not to mention the institutionalization of human trafficking, which we hear so much about in the news. Just because someone thinks that selling their body for money is a good idea and a way to make tons of "easy" cash, does not mean it IS a good idea or that we should we allow them to do it. It is not until after-the-fact, after someone has already sold their body, that they realize what they have truly gotten themselves into.

It's difficult to explain to someone that in return for that "easy" cash, they will in fact be selling their very soul. A soul cannot properly exist within a body that eventually turns on itself because of the level of hate one inevitably internalizes. Just try to deal with lying on a bed, in a car, in a field or wherever and have someone do the most intimate act that can be done between two people, and block it out of your conscious thoughts. Eventually and inevitably, one's mind can take no more, and you are taken to another, deeper level of detaching yourself from your body.


1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 next








Tags:

Comments

I think this editorial is so

By angie, May 13, 2007 at 00:10

I think this editorial is so well written and full of truth - I attended the prelim on the behalf of my dear friend's daughter - so this case is very near and dear to me - Trisha - you are a beautiful person and your writings are more near to the truth than I think I have ever heard - keep up the good work - and may God continue to bless you and have you bless others like you are doing!

One of the things I noticed

By larsmith, March 3, 2007 at 07:01

One of the things I noticed in Trisha's article was some attention given to why young girls and even mature women sell their sexuality to others.

I sat here, reading to my wife some of the comments. I wanted to know if she saw any common cause for men going to prostitutes and women becoming prostitutes. One common thread is _selfishness_. Men selfishly want physical gratification and the women want ... well ... according to Trisha, they want attention, affection, money ( "EASY" money ) ... etc.

I find it interesting that responses to this article have touched on capitalism and other things which are similarly fueled by selfishness; things like high corporate profits, etc.

It might also be observed that pre-marital sex of any kind is often a result of selfishness.

I think it was the internationally recognized Dr. James Dobson whom I first heard say that men give up affection for sex and women give up sex for affection. Hearing it from a conservative like James Dobson is one thing ... and I'd wager that many women would take exception to his comments in this area.

As I read thru Trisha's article, I began to realize that she was saying pretty well the same thing. SOME of the girls / women who get involved in prostitution do so because of their deep ( if not unexplainable ) desire for affection ... for approval, not just for the money.

Regarding the objectification of women, I have this to say.

Objectification of women ( ie: women being viewed as sex objects, used for some selfish gain or gratification ) does not always happen passively to women but is something in which many women actively & pro-actively are involved. The women who are so common in commercials today probably have NOT had their arm twisted to be in the commercial. Few if any of the women who make up the Dallas Cheerleaders have had their arms twisted to appear for the try-outs and for the subsequent competition which goes on for one of the most coveted positions on what may well be the most famous cheer leading squad.

These women don't just "become objectified" but are rather actively involved in becoming objectified. Each has her own motivation, perhaps, but I'm going to respectfully suggest that when all is said and done, most if not all of them are in it for selfish reasons, whether it be money or recognition or to feel like they're not ugly and/or miriad other possibilities, all of which are self-centered.

There is a reasonable distaste both for prostitutes and johns and crooked lawyers and selfish corporate executives, for liars, murderers and thieves, for war-mongering presidents & prime ministers, pedophile reverends and slacker union members, for non-productive tenured professors who have students do all the research for which they take credit and for parents who spend all their family income on drugs or gambling.

Interestingly enough, each of these people have one thing in common and that is selfishness.

Trisha said something about a void inside that so many people try to fill. The desire to have that vacuum filled is what drives many men to porn and to hookers, it's what drives many women to become hookers, it's what drives some politicians to become crooked, it's what drives heroin addicts to take that first injection.

The problem is not sex or prostitution or drugs or anger or needles or money.

Until we discover what the real problem is, we'll continue to have prostitutes, serial killers, crooked politicians and police men and judges and professors, we'll continue to have johns and pimps and parents who grieve because their child is lying there, in a casket.

We need to learn more about the void inside, to which Trisha alluded, and we need to learn now to fill that void.

Until we discover, individually and collectively, what or Who can fill that void, we will remain the selfish creatures we are. We will continue to seek physical and emotional things to fill the void and we will continue to experience what Trisha alluded to and that is that the void will get BIGGER, not smaller.

It's an enigma ... even a paradox ... that the more selfish we are and the more of our lives that we dedicate to selfishness, the more dissatisfied we become. The more we try to satiate our inner void, the more insatiable that void ... that VACUUM ... becomes.

Does any reader know how that void can be filled ?

YES - Jesus can fill that

By angie, May 13, 2007 at 00:06

YES - Jesus can fill that void!

From time immemorial,

By Goose Egg, February 23, 2007 at 13:13

From time immemorial, despite the advent of civilisation, it has always been a Men's world and Women has been been classified as an object of sex and enjoyment. Even the description of heaven in Christianity(or. Swarg in Hindu, Jannat in Islam, execpt in tribal societies and religion where women has a higher place ), describes it to be a place where Men can have unlimited pleasure of the company of the angels and virgins.
Added to that, in the present age of free market, unlimited freedom of expression, of unlimited consumerism and the media's portrayal of young women as sex objects and selling of sex and sexuality for promoting all and sundries (be it selling a merchandise or raising funds or awareness for any good cause like AIDS, PETA etc.);all of them, the magazines, television, video games and music videos all indulges in sexualisation of young girls, projecting them on her sexual appeal or behaviour, to the exclusion of other characteristics, and have a detrimental effect on the young girls and women.

As a society, we need to replace all these sexualised images with ones showing girls in positive settings - ones that show the uniqueness and competence of girls. The goal should be to deliver messages to all adolescents- boys and girls- that lead to healthy sexual development and the key thing here is social responsibility.

But in a bourgeoise society, plagued by the consumerist and capitalist forces, there is no place for human qualities like ethics, morality and integrity as they are not of any market value. In the highly corporatorised and institutionalised world of today, all that matters is profit, more profit and only profit, everything else which is not having a market value are expendable.

They can go to any extent from dehumanising humans, bribing, threatning or eliminating people ( like recent orato.com story of Oil giant Exxon, bribing scientists to issue statement that the global worming and climate changes are not due to burning of fossil fuels)to even exterminate a 3rd of world population (believe me, I'm not talking of any conspiracy theory)who are considered a drain on the earth's limited resources and of no market value. A plan to this effect has already been in place by the group of 200 super rich families of big businesses, few royals, politicians and the likes, who have enormous clout over the power structure of this planet.

But lets leave that for now and thank Trisha for her well written and meaningful article from her own life experience.

Shyamal Barua.
gooegg@gmail.com

Legalization of AL OF IT

By wolfhart, February 25, 2007 at 07:52

Legalization of AL OF IT DRUGS-EVERTHING/And do way with RELIGION

It wasn't God who killed

By angie, May 13, 2007 at 00:43

It wasn't God who killed Brenda - it was
SIN in the most evil form - and yes, PORN has a big part in this picture - please try and see it for what it is and stop blaming God because he truly loves you and Brenda - it is not his doing, but MAN'S!!!!

These are really important

By Heather Wallace, February 22, 2007 at 19:47

These are really important arguments, Trisha. More of the women would be alive if they worked in an establishment. But the fact their lives were on the line because of the nature of their work is what we have to look at. And why these women made the choices that they did - often making them when they were just babies as young as 10 or 11 years old, when they first ended up on the streets.

I personally take a more liberal approach to sex outside of marriage. After all, these days, it doesn't always make financial or spiritual sense to get married. Some people can choose not to marry, but still have sex in good faith. But I believe you are right in your assertion that it is best within the context of a mutually-respectful and meaningful relationship. And I think you're also right in your assertion that the media is saturated with the objectification of women.

Thank you for asking us to look at what it was about these women that caused them to turn away from us and from themselves. (I think it's one of the few unfortunate times when we can draw a distinction between 'us' and 'them.' There is someting that divided them/us so much that they died.)

*****

I was at court the other day and I overheard a victim's family member talking about his daughter. Her death is not involved in this trial, which addresses the murder of six of the women, but part of the next trial, which deals with 20 more cases and counts of murder. This father said he is frustrated because not all the women murdered/missing were "drug-addicted prostitutes," as reported in the media.

I'm interested in knowing more about that...

I know reducing the women to "drug-addicted prostitutes" is problematic linguistically, politically and socially. The women were many other things. But it's my understanding that all the women murdered were, in fact, addicted to drugs and involved in the sex trade. But all had nonetheless fallen so far down the social scale, that they were likely involved in a "survival lifestyle." I don't doubt many were young girls when they began in the trade, and it is not only the women we must remember, but the girls they still were when they fell down in the first place.

If that father wants to set the record straight, and tell me why they weren't all drug-addicted prostitutes, and if his story is not off limits according to any publication bans, I invite him to contact me at heather@orato.

Heather Wallace
senior editor

Why didn't you just ask him?

By angie, May 13, 2007 at 00:15

Why didn't you just ask him? Chances are he has never even heard of this site. Many family members haven't!

Editor's Picks

Darfur Refugees: Don't Press-Gang Our Sons

By Citizen Correspondent Anna Schmitt
Through my humanitarian work in Central Africa, I learned that refugee children from... Full Story »